Updated November 2026

Choosing a butterball professional series turkey fryer comes down to four things: how much turkey you need to cook at once, whether you will fry indoors or outdoors, how much counter or patio space you have, and how comfortable you are managing hot oil. This guide compares six Butterball-branded and Masterbuilt-made options against those criteria. We looked at published specifications, brand reputation for the Butterball and Masterbuilt lines, and recurring patterns in owner feedback about capacity, heat-up time, cleanup, and build quality.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1Masterbuilt Butterball MB23012418 XL Electric FryerTOP CHOICEBest overallMasterbuilt Butterball MB23012418 XL Electric FryerView on Amazon
  2. 2Masterbuilt Butterball XXL Digital Indoor Electric Turkey FryerTOP CHOICEBest for large gatheringsMasterbuilt Butterball XXL Digital Indoor Electric Turkey FryerView on Amazon
  3. 3Butterball Stainless Steel 14LB Indoor Electric Turkey FryerTOP CHOICEBest for small kitchensButterball Stainless Steel 14LB Indoor Electric Turkey FryerView on Amazon
  4. 4Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, BlackBest budget pickMasterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, BlackView on Amazon
  5. 5Butterball 10 Liter XL Electric FryerBest for year-round useButterball 10 Liter XL Electric FryerView on Amazon
  6. 6Char-Broil The Big Easy Oil-Less Turkey FryerBest oil-free alternativeChar-Broil The Big Easy Oil-Less Turkey FryerView on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Quick Comparison

Product Best for Key feature
Masterbuilt Butterball MB23012418 XL Electric Fryer Most households frying one turkey Electric heating element with thermostat control
Masterbuilt Butterball XXL Digital Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer Large gatherings and big birds Largest-capacity model in the line, digital controls
Butterball Stainless Steel 14LB Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer Small kitchens and smaller birds Stainless steel cooking pot, sized for birds up to about 14 lb
Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, Black Budget-conscious buyers Indoor use rated for birds up to 14 lb
Butterball 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer Year-round frying of more than turkey 10-liter capacity for side dishes and seafood
Char-Broil The Big Easy Oil-Less Turkey Fryer Buyers who want no oil and no open flame Oil-less cooking method, outdoor use

Masterbuilt Butterball MB23012418 XL Electric Fryer

Masterbuilt Butterball MB23012418 XL Electric Fryer

Masterbuilt Butterball MB23012418 XL Electric Fryer

View on Amazon

Best for: Most households frying one turkey

This is a good fit for families who want a dedicated electric fryer for a single holiday bird and expect to fry a few other foods through the year. Its electric design removes the open flame and the need to handle large volumes of oil over a burner.

Key specs

  • Electric heating element with a built-in thermostat
  • Butterball-branded model within the Masterbuilt XL range
  • Designed for indoor or covered use per manufacturer guidance

Pros

  • No open flame or propane tank to manage
  • Thermostat control makes oil temperature easier to hold steady
  • Suits a family-size turkey without requiring a commercial-size unit

Cons

  • Capacity is smaller than the XXL model for very large birds
  • Electric units can take a while to bring oil up to temperature

Bottom line: A solid default choice for a standard holiday turkey and occasional frying through the year.

View on Amazon

Masterbuilt Butterball XXL Digital Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer

Masterbuilt Butterball XXL Digital Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer (Largest Capacity, Newest Model) (Red)

Masterbuilt Butterball XXL Digital Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer (Largest Capacity, Newest Model) (Red)

View on Amazon

Best for: Large gatherings and big birds

This model is aimed at cooks who regularly feed a crowd or want the option of a larger bird than a standard fryer can hold. The digital controls suit anyone who prefers setting a precise temperature and timer rather than watching a dial.

Key specs

  • XXL capacity, the largest size in the Butterball electric line
  • Digital controls for temperature and cook time
  • Indoor electric operation

Pros

  • Handles larger birds than most standard fryers
  • Digital display makes it easier to read and set temperature
  • Electric heat removes the need for a propane burner outdoors

Cons

  • Large footprint needs real counter or floor space
  • Heavier to move once filled with oil

Bottom line: Best if you cook for a big group and have the space to store and operate a large appliance.

View on Amazon

Butterball Stainless Steel 14LB Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer

BUTTERBALL STAINLESS STEEL14LB INDOOR ELECTRIC TURKEY FRYER - also Fry & steam and boil all your favorite foods, butterball professional series by MASTERBUILT - USE YEAR ROUND - 1650 WATTS

BUTTERBALL STAINLESS STEEL14LB INDOOR ELECTRIC TURKEY FRYER – also Fry & steam and boil all your favorite foods, butterball professional series by MASTERBUILT – USE YEAR ROUND – 1650 WATTS

View on Amazon

Best for: Small kitchens

This fryer is sized for a turkey up to about 14 pounds, which fits smaller households and holiday meals with fewer guests. Its stainless steel construction appeals to buyers who want a more durable finish than painted metal.

Key specs

  • Rated for turkeys up to 14 lb
  • Stainless steel finish
  • 1650 watts, indoor electric operation
  • Also marketed for steaming and boiling, per the listing

Pros

  • Compact enough for smaller kitchens
  • Stainless finish is easier to keep clean than many painted surfaces
  • Can be used for other foods beyond turkey

Cons

  • Capacity limits it to smaller birds
  • Not ideal if you plan to cook a 16 lb or larger turkey

Bottom line: A practical pick for couples, small families, or anyone who wants a smaller footprint.

View on Amazon

Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, Black

Masterbuilt - Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer - Black - 1650 WATTS - COMMERICAL GRADED - FOR HOME OR BUSINESS USE - FITS 14LB TURKEY

Masterbuilt – Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer – Black – 1650 WATTS – COMMERICAL GRADED – FOR HOME OR BUSINESS USE – FITS 14LB TURKEY

View on Amazon

Best for: Budget-conscious buyers

This is a straightforward indoor electric fryer for buyers who want the Butterball-branded electric approach without paying for extra features. It suits a single holiday turkey and does not need much setup.

Key specs

  • 1650 watts, indoor electric operation
  • Rated for turkeys up to 14 lb
  • Black finish

Pros

  • Simple, no-frills design
  • Indoor electric use avoids propane and open flame
  • Fits a standard family-size turkey

Cons

  • Fewer convenience features than the digital XXL model
  • Capacity is limited to smaller birds

Bottom line: A sensible choice if you want a basic electric fryer for one turkey and little else.

View on Amazon

Butterball 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer

23011615 Butterball 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer

23011615 Butterball 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer

View on Amazon

Best for: Year-round frying of more than turkey

The 10-liter capacity makes this useful for frying chicken parts, seafood, or side dishes between holidays. Buyers who want one appliance for many jobs tend to focus on this kind of model.

Key specs

  • 10-liter oil capacity
  • Electric heating
  • Butterball branding

Pros

  • Useful for everyday frying, not only holidays
  • Electric operation keeps the setup simple
  • Moderate size for typical home kitchens

Cons

  • Check the listing carefully for maximum turkey size before buying
  • Oil volume means cleanup and storage take planning

Bottom line: Best for cooks who want a fryer they will use beyond Thanksgiving.

View on Amazon

Char-Broil The Big Easy Oil-Less Turkey Fryer

Charbroil The Big Easy Oil-Less Turkey Fryer | Outdoor Air Fryer | Propane Cooker | Black

Charbroil The Big Easy Oil-Less Turkey Fryer | Outdoor Air Fryer | Propane Cooker | Black

View on Amazon

Best for: Buyers who want no oil and no open flame

This is a different cooking method from a traditional oil fryer. It suits cooks who want crisp results without handling large amounts of hot oil, and who are comfortable with outdoor use.

Key specs

  • Oil-less cooking method
  • Designed as an outdoor cooker
  • Propane-powered per the product category

Pros

  • No large volume of oil to heat, store, or dispose of
  • Lower oil-related safety concerns than deep frying
  • Can cook other foods beyond turkey

Cons

  • Results and cook times differ from classic deep-fried turkey
  • Requires a propane tank and outdoor space

Bottom line: A good alternative if you want a less oil-intensive method and have outdoor room.

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Capacity and Turkey Size

Check the maximum turkey weight the manufacturer lists, not just the fryer’s oil capacity. Many Butterball electric models are rated for birds up to about 14 pounds, while XXL and larger units accept bigger birds. Buy for the largest turkey you realistically expect to cook.

Good picks for this: Masterbuilt Butterball XXL Digital Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, Butterball Stainless Steel 14LB Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer

Indoor Versus Outdoor Use

Electric fryers are generally marketed for indoor or covered use, while propane fryers belong outdoors. Confirm the intended location in the owner’s manual before you plug in or light anything. Indoor use still requires a clear, level surface away from walls and cabinets.

Good picks for this: Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, Black, Char-Broil The Big Easy Oil-Less Turkey Fryer

Heating Method and Temperature Control

Electric units use a heating element with a thermostat, which tends to keep oil temperature steadier than open-flame setups. Digital displays make it easier to set and read the target temperature. Consistent oil temperature is one of the main factors in a crisp, evenly cooked bird.

Good picks for this: Masterbuilt Butterball XXL Digital Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, Masterbuilt Butterball MB23012418 XL Electric Fryer

Size and Storage Footprint

Measure the counter, floor, or patio space before ordering. Large fryers are heavy when filled with oil, so plan for a stable surface and a clear path to carry or drain the unit. Also check where you will store the fryer between seasons.

Good picks for this: Butterball Stainless Steel 14LB Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, Butterball 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer

Multi-Use Capability

If you plan to fry chicken, seafood, or vegetables during the rest of the year, a larger oil capacity and a versatile design will get more use from the appliance. Check whether the manufacturer recommends it for foods other than turkey.

Good picks for this: Butterball 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer, Butterball Stainless Steel 14LB Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer

Build Quality and Durability

Stainless steel finishes resist staining and are generally easier to wipe clean than painted surfaces. Look at lid fit, handle attachment, and the basket or rack design. Owners often report that sturdy handles and secure lids make the biggest day-to-day difference.

Good picks for this: Butterball Stainless Steel 14LB Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, Masterbuilt Butterball XXL Digital Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer

Safety Features and Manual Requirements

Read the full owner’s manual before the first use, and follow its minimum clearances, thawing rules, and oil-level limits. Never leave a fryer unattended while it is running. Check that the cord, plug, and heating element are in good condition. If you have questions about electrical safety in your home, consult a licensed electrician.

Good picks for this: Masterbuilt Butterball MB23012418 XL Electric Fryer, Char-Broil The Big Easy Oil-Less Turkey Fryer

FAQ

What size turkey can a Butterball professional series fryer handle?

It depends on the model. Many Butterball indoor electric fryers are rated for turkeys up to about 14 pounds, while XXL-class units accept larger birds. Always confirm the maximum weight in the specifications for the exact model you buy.

Is an electric Butterball turkey fryer safe to use indoors?

Indoor electric models are designed for indoor use when set up according to the manual. Keep the unit on a stable, level surface, away from walls, cabinets, and curtains, and never leave it running unattended. Homeowners with questions about their wiring should consult a licensed electrician.

How long does it take to fry a turkey in an electric fryer?

Cook time depends on the bird’s weight and the model. Follow the timing chart in the owner’s manual and check that the internal temperature of the thickest part of the breast and thigh reaches the safe minimum. A food thermometer is the only reliable way to confirm doneness.

Can I fry foods other than turkey in these fryers?

Many owners use Butterball electric fryers for chicken, seafood, and side dishes. Check the manual for approved uses and oil recommendations, and do not exceed the stated oil capacity.

What type of oil should I use?

Manufacturers commonly recommend peanut or other high smoke-point oils for deep frying. Follow the oil type and volume listed in your owner’s manual, and never mix oil types.

Do I need a thawed turkey?

Yes. A fully thawed bird is strongly recommended to prevent dangerous oil splatter and uneven cooking. Thaw in the refrigerator according to USDA guidance, allowing roughly one day for every four to five pounds.

How do I clean an electric turkey fryer?

Let the oil cool fully before draining it through the manufacturer’s recommended method. Wipe the pot and heating element according to the manual, and avoid submerging electrical parts. Store the unit dry and covered.

Conclusion

For most households frying a single holiday turkey, the Masterbuilt Butterball MB23012418 XL Electric Fryer is a balanced starting point. Cooks who feed large groups should look at the Masterbuilt Butterball XXL Digital Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, while those with small kitchens may prefer the Butterball Stainless Steel 14LB Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer. The Butterball 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer suits year-round frying, and the Char-Broil The Big Easy Oil-Less Turkey Fryer is the option for buyers who want to avoid deep frying in oil. Match the turkey size, space, and cooking location to your needs, and read the owner’s manual before your first use.

Sources

Ethan Brooks

About Ethan Brooks

Ethan Brooks is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our holiday cooking & baking guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.