Updated November 2026

Finding replacement parts for Butterball turkey fryer units can be frustrating, especially when a cord frays, a drain valve starts leaking or a basket goes missing before the holiday meal. This roundup covers four replacement parts that fit Butterball-branded electric turkey fryers and the closely related Masterbuilt XL models. Our selection focuses on model compatibility, material quality, how well each listing matches a common failure point and owner feedback patterns. Check your model number against each listing before you buy.

Note: This comparison is based on published listing details, manufacturer specifications and general owner feedback patterns. We have not physically tested these parts.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1Valve Spout Kit Replacement Parts for Masterbuilt 10 Liter XL Electric FryerTOP CHOICEBest overallValve Spout Kit Replacement Parts for Masterbuilt 10 Liter XL Electric FryerView on Amazon
  2. 2Deep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base for Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer PartsBest for a misplaced or damaged cordDeep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base for Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer PartsView on Amazon
  3. 3VASTHOME Deep Fryer Cord Replacement for Hamilton Beach, Masterbuilt,Best budget pickVASTHOME Deep Fryer Cord Replacement for Hamilton Beach, Masterbuilt,View on Amazon
  4. 4Turkey Basket Replacement Part for Masterbuilt 10 Liter XL Electric FryerBest for basket replacementTurkey Basket Replacement Part for Masterbuilt 10 Liter XL Electric FryerView on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Quick Comparison

Product Best for Key feature
Valve Spout Kit Replacement Parts for Masterbuilt 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer Replacing a leaking or damaged oil drain Drain spout, safety cap and seal kit
Deep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base for Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer Parts Restoring a lost or damaged power connection Cord with base and magnetic connection
VASTHOME Deep Fryer Cord Replacement Budget-conscious cord swaps 16 AWG flat power cord
Turkey Basket Replacement Part for Masterbuilt 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer Replacing a missing or bent basket Chrome-plated wire construction

Valve Spout Kit Replacement Parts for Masterbuilt 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer

Valve Spout Kit Replacement Parts for Masterbuilt 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer, Oil Drain Spout, Safety Cap and Seal Kit Parts for Masterbuilt XL Electric Turkey Deep Fryer MB20012420, MB20010326

Valve Spout Kit Replacement Parts for Masterbuilt 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer, Oil Drain Spout, Safety Cap and Seal Kit Parts for Masterbuilt XL Electric Turkey Deep Fryer MB20012420, MB20010326

View on Amazon

Best for: Replacing a leaking or damaged oil drain valve on a 10-liter XL electric turkey fryer.

This kit suits owners whose drain spout has cracked, stopped sealing or lost its safety cap. Draining hot oil is one of the riskier steps in electric frying, so a reliable valve matters.

Key specs

  • Designed for the 10-liter Masterbuilt XL electric fryer line
  • Listing names compatibility with model numbers MB20012420 and MB20010326
  • Includes oil drain spout, safety cap and seal kit

Pros

  • Covers the drain spout and seals in one kit
  • Model numbers are listed clearly for matching
  • Addresses one of the most common leak points

Cons

  • Installation may require some care to avoid overtightening
  • Only useful if the drain valve is the actual problem

Bottom line: Best for owners of compatible Masterbuilt XL units who see oil seeping from the drain area. Confirm your model number first.

View on Amazon

Deep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base for Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer Parts

Deep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base for Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer Parts and Masterbuilt Turkey Fryer Cord Fits 1650W Models Magnetic Cable for Misplaced Cord Replacement MB20012420 MB20010326

Deep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base for Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer Parts and Masterbuilt Turkey Fryer Cord Fits 1650W Models Magnetic Cable for Misplaced Cord Replacement MB20012420 MB20010326

View on Amazon

Best for: Replacing a lost, damaged or misplaced power cord on compatible Butterball and Masterbuilt electric fryers.

This option is aimed at owners who need a complete cord-and-base setup rather than a bare wire. It is a practical choice when the original cord has been cut, pinched or misplaced.

Key specs

  • Listed for 1650W models
  • Includes base and magnetic cable connection
  • Listing names compatibility with model numbers MB20012420 and MB20010326

Pros

  • Includes the base, not just the cord
  • Magnetic connection is convenient for storage
  • Compatibility is spelled out by model number

Cons

  • Magnetic connectors can be less secure than fixed cords if bumped
  • Owners of non-listed models will need to confirm fit

Bottom line: A good pick for owners who need a full power-connection replacement on a supported model.

View on Amazon

VASTHOME Deep Fryer Cord Replacement for Hamilton Beach, Masterbuilt, Butterball, Farberware, Secura, and Pukomc Electric Deep Fryers

VASTHOME Deep Fryer Cord Replacement for Hamilton Beach, Masterbuilt, Butterball, Farberware, Secura, and Pukomc Electric Deep Fryers - 16 AWG Flat Power Cord Replacement Part

VASTHOME Deep Fryer Cord Replacement for Hamilton Beach, Masterbuilt, Butterball, Farberware, Secura, and Pukomc Electric Deep Fryers – 16 AWG Flat Power Cord Replacement Part

View on Amazon

Best for: Budget-conscious cord replacement across several electric fryer brands.

This is a bare replacement cord rather than a cord-and-base set. It suits owners comfortable with a simple swap who want a lower-cost option for a damaged cord.

Key specs

  • 16 AWG flat power cord
  • Listed for several electric fryer brands, including Butterball and Masterbuilt

Pros

  • Straightforward replacement cord
  • Lists multiple compatible brands
  • Simple option for a basic repair

Cons

  • Does not include a base, so it may not suit every connection style
  • Multi-brand listings require careful confirmation of your specific model

Bottom line: A sensible choice for a straightforward cord swap when you have verified the connector and wattage match your unit.

View on Amazon

Turkey Basket Replacement Part for Masterbuilt 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer

Turkey Basket Replacement Part for Masterbuilt 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer, Chrome Plated Wire Turkey Basket Replacement Part & Accessories for Masterbuilt 10L XL Deep Fryer MB20012420, MB20010326

Turkey Basket Replacement Part for Masterbuilt 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer, Chrome Plated Wire Turkey Basket Replacement Part & Accessories for Masterbuilt 10L XL Deep Fryer MB20012420, MB20010326

View on Amazon

Best for: Replacing a missing, bent or worn turkey basket on a 10-liter XL electric fryer.

Owners who have lost the original basket or find the wire frame warped after several seasons will find this useful. A properly fitting basket keeps the bird centered and makes lowering and lifting safer.

Key specs

  • Chrome-plated wire construction
  • Listed for 10-liter Masterbuilt XL models MB20012420 and MB20010326

Pros

  • Chrome plating helps resist surface wear
  • Model-specific listing reduces fit guesswork
  • Restores a critical frying accessory

Cons

  • Fit must be verified against the original basket dimensions
  • Wire baskets can still bend if a heavy bird is handled roughly

Bottom line: Best for owners who need a direct basket replacement on a supported 10-liter XL model.

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Confirm Your Exact Model Number

Butterball-branded and Masterbuilt-branded electric fryers share design elements, but sizes and connectors differ. Look for the model number on the label or base of the unit before ordering. Manufacturers typically specify compatible parts by model, so this is the single most important check.

Good picks for this: Valve Spout Kit Replacement Parts for Masterbuilt 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer, Turkey Basket Replacement Part for Masterbuilt 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer

Cord Type and Wattage

Power cords vary in gauge, length and connector style. Match the wattage rating of your fryer (listed on the nameplate) and check whether the replacement includes a base or only the cable. A 16 AWG cord is a common gauge for this class of appliance, but always confirm against your unit’s specifications.

Good picks for this: Deep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base for Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer Parts, VASTHOME Deep Fryer Cord Replacement

Drain Valve and Seal Condition

If oil is seeping from the lower part of the fryer, inspect the drain spout, cap and seals before assuming the pot is cracked. A kit that includes seals can address several potential leak points at once. Drain and cool the unit completely before handling any valve components.

Good picks for this: Valve Spout Kit Replacement Parts for Masterbuilt 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer

Basket Size and Fit

The basket must sit securely inside the cooking pot without touching the heating element. Measure the diameter and height of your original basket if it still exists, and compare those figures with the listing. A basket that is too large or too small can create uneven cooking or an unsafe lift.

Good picks for this: Turkey Basket Replacement Part for Masterbuilt 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer

Material and Corrosion Resistance

Chrome-plated or stainless components tend to hold up better to repeated oil exposure and cleaning than uncoated steel. Owners often report that surface finish matters more on baskets than on cords. Dry all metal parts thoroughly after washing to limit rust.

Good picks for this: Turkey Basket Replacement Part for Masterbuilt 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer, Valve Spout Kit Replacement Parts for Masterbuilt 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer

Storage and Connection Convenience

Magnetic or detachable cord connections can make storage easier, but they should be checked periodically for secure contact. Keep cords coiled loosely and away from hot surfaces. Avoid running cords under the fryer or near heat sources.

Good picks for this: Deep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base for Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer Parts

Use Frequency and Durability

A fryer used once a year experiences different wear than one used for multiple events. Consider how often you fry and whether you need a premium replacement that will last or a budget pick for an occasional repair. Replacing a worn part early is often safer than waiting for a failure during use.

Good picks for this: VASTHOME Deep Fryer Cord Replacement, Valve Spout Kit Replacement Parts for Masterbuilt 10 Liter XL Electric Fryer

FAQ

Do these parts fit all Butterball turkey fryers?

No. The listings reference specific Masterbuilt XL model numbers, and some cords are listed for multiple brands. Always compare the model number on your unit with the compatibility details in each listing before purchasing.

How do I know if I need a new drain valve or just new seals?

Start by drying the area and checking where the leak appears. If the seal around the spout is damaged, a seal kit may be enough. If the spout itself is cracked or the cap no longer closes properly, a full valve spout kit is the better choice.

Is a bare cord as good as a cord with a base?

Both can work if the connector and wattage match your fryer. A cord with a base can be simpler to install because the connection is included. A bare cord is often less expensive but requires you to verify the terminal fit yourself.

Can I use a basket from a different fryer brand?

It is not recommended unless the dimensions match precisely. A basket that is too large can touch the heating element, and one that is too small can allow food to shift during frying. Use a basket listed for your specific model.

How should I clean replacement parts after frying?

Allow the fryer and parts to cool fully. Wash metal components with warm water and mild dish soap, dry them thoroughly and store them away from moisture. Keep electrical components, such as cords and connectors, out of standing water.

When should I stop using a damaged fryer and replace it instead?

If the heating element, thermostat or pot is cracked, or if the unit shows electrical faults such as sparking or tripping, stop using it. Electrical repairs and pot damage carry real safety risks. Consult a qualified appliance repair professional or the manufacturer before continuing use.

Conclusion

For a leaking drain, the valve spout kit is the most targeted fix. For a damaged or missing power connection, the cord with base offers a complete replacement, while the VASTHOME cord suits a simpler, lower-cost swap. If the turkey basket has gone missing or warped, the chrome-plated basket restores that core accessory. Match each part to your specific model number, and when in doubt about electrical or pot damage, consult a qualified professional rather than attempting a repair you are unsure of.

Sources

Ethan Brooks

About Ethan Brooks

Ethan Brooks is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our holiday cooking & baking guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.