Updated November 2026
The Masterbuilt Butterball turkey fryer XL is an indoor-rated electric fryer designed to cook a whole turkey with hot oil, using a basket and heating element sized for holiday birds. By the end of this guide, you will know how to choose the right bird size, prepare and season the turkey, set up the fryer safely, time the cook, and handle cleanup. Owners often report that the electric design makes the process more predictable than propane, but the same core safety rules still apply.
What the Masterbuilt Butterball Turkey Fryer XL Does
The Masterbuilt Butterball turkey fryer XL is an electric fryer built around a removable cooking basket, a heating element, and a temperature control. Because it uses electricity instead of an open flame, it is usually sold as suitable for indoor use in a garage, carport or other covered space, though manufacturers specify exactly where and how it may be operated, so check the manual before you plug it in. The fryer is designed to bring a measured volume of cooking oil to a set temperature and hold it there while the turkey cooks.
Shopping for one? See our guide: 5 Best Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Turkey Fryer Options for Holiday Cooking.
If you are comparing this model to other options, our guide to 7 Best Masterbuilt Butterball Xl Electric Turkey Fryers (2026): Our Picks lays out how the lineup differs, and 5 Best Masterbuilt XL Turkey Fryer Models Compared (2026) covers related sizes.
Before You Start: Sizing, Oil and Equipment
Good results begin before the fryer is switched on. Work through these decisions first.
Choose the Right Turkey Size
Check the fryer’s stated maximum bird weight in the manual and never exceed it. Most manufacturers list a weight limit for their basket, and a bird that is too large can make the basket hard to lower safely and can cause the oil to overflow. Measure the bird inside the fryer by placing it in the empty basket and filling with water to the cover line, which is a common method for checking displacement. Remove the bird, dry the pot and make a note of the water level.
Pick the Right Oil
Peanut oil is widely used for frying turkey because of its high smoke point and mild flavor, though some cooks choose refined canola or other high-smoke-point oils. Use the oil quantity the manufacturer specifies, which is usually well below the maximum fill line once the turkey is added. Do not reuse oil that has been heavily used or smells rancid.
Gather Your Tools
Have everything within reach before the turkey goes in:
- A digital meat thermometer with a probe that reads to at least 180°F
- Heat-resistant gloves and an apron
- A long-handled lifter or hook for the basket
- Paper towels and a clean, thick towel for drying the bird
- A fire extinguisher rated for grease fires (Class K or Class B), kept nearby
- A large tray or cooling rack for resting the finished bird
Step-by-Step: Frying a Turkey in the Masterbuilt Butterball Turkey Fryer XL
Step 1: Thaw the Turkey Completely
Thaw the turkey in the refrigerator, allowing roughly 24 hours for every 4 to 5 pounds. A bird that is still partly frozen will cause dangerous oil splatter and uneven cooking. Pat the turkey dry inside and out, removing giblets and neck. Dry skin browns better and reduces spatter.
Step 2: Season and Prepare the Bird
Inject or rub seasoning as you prefer, but keep liquid marinades to a minimum, since excess moisture increases splatter. Some cooks truss the legs loosely and secure the wings to keep the bird compact. Make sure the turkey is completely dry before lowering it in.
Step 3: Set Up the Fryer on a Stable, Safe Surface
Place the fryer on a flat, level, non-flammable surface, well away from walls, structures, and overhanging items. Keep children and pets out of the area. Plug the fryer into a grounded outlet rated for the load, and do not use an extension cord unless the manufacturer allows it. Check the cord for damage before use.
Step 4: Add Oil and Preheat
Add the measured oil to the pot, then set the temperature control according to the manual. Preheat until the oil reaches the target temperature, commonly listed in the 350°F range for turkey. Keep the lid off during preheating so you can watch the oil, and never leave it unattended.
Step 5: Lower the Turkey Slowly
Turn the heat off or down as the manual directs before lowering the bird. Lower the basket slowly and steadily, keeping your face and body back from the pot. Watch for bubbling, which is normal, but stop if the oil foams up near the rim. Turn the heat back on and bring the oil back to temperature.
Step 6: Monitor Cooking Time and Temperature
Cooking time depends on bird weight, oil temperature and how full the fryer is, so use the timing chart in your manual as a starting point rather than a guarantee. Check the internal temperature in the thickest part of the breast and the thigh, aiming for 165°F in the breast and 175°F or higher in the thigh, which is the standard food-safety guidance from the USDA. Confirm with a thermometer rather than relying on the clock.
Step 7: Lift, Drain and Rest
Turn off the fryer, then lift the basket slowly and hold it over the pot to drain. Move the bird to a rack or tray and let it rest for about 20 to 30 minutes before carving. Resting keeps juices in the meat and makes carving cleaner.
Timing Your Holiday Cook
A fried turkey cooks faster than a roasted one, which is part of its appeal. The table below shows an example timeline for a single-day cook. Adjust for your bird and your oven or serving schedule.
| Stage | Approximate timing | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Thaw (refrigerator) | About 24 hours per 4–5 lb | Start two to three days before |
| Prep and season | 30–45 minutes | Dry the bird thoroughly |
| Preheat oil | 20–30 minutes | Verify target temperature |
| Fry | Follow manual chart | Check internal temperature near the end |
| Rest | 20–30 minutes | Carve just before serving |
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Frying a partly frozen bird. Ice causes violent splatter. Thaw fully.
- Overfilling the pot. Exceeding the oil or water line can cause overflow when the turkey is added.
- Using wet skin or marinade. Moisture is the main cause of popping and spatter.
- Leaving the fryer unattended. Hot oil can ignite or overheat quickly.
- Skipping the thermometer. Color and timing alone are unreliable indicators of doneness.
- Operating in an unsuitable location. Follow the manual’s placement rules, especially around walls, overhangs and garages.
Tips for Better Results
- Run a test cycle with water before cooking oil to learn how the unit heats and holds temperature.
- Keep the lid nearby but off until the oil is at temperature.
- Write down your bird weight, oil volume and cook time so you can repeat or adjust next year.
- If you are new to this process, practice with a smaller test bird first.
Recommended gear
A few supporting items make the process easier and safer. A digital probe thermometer lets you check the breast and thigh without opening the fryer. View on Amazon
A long-handled turkey lifter or hook helps you lower and raise the basket without leaning over hot oil. View on Amazon
A Class K fire extinguisher is designed for cooking oil fires and is worth keeping within reach. View on Amazon
Heat-resistant frying gloves protect your hands during setup and lifting. View on Amazon
For more options on oil and cookware, see 5 Best Oils for Turkey Fryer Options for Holiday Frying (2026) and Turkey Fryer Deep Fryer Guide: Safe Setup, Oil Use and Frying Steps.
FAQ
Can I use the Masterbuilt Butterball turkey fryer XL indoors?
The fryer is marketed as an indoor-capable electric unit, but manufacturers still specify placement, ventilation and clearance requirements. Read the manual and follow those limits exactly.
How long does a turkey take in the fryer?
Times vary with weight and oil temperature. Use the manual’s timing chart as a starting point, and always confirm doneness with a thermometer, targeting 165°F in the breast and 175°F or higher in the thigh.
What oil should I use?
Peanut oil is common for its high smoke point and mild taste, but refined canola or other high-smoke-point oils are also used. Use the quantity the manufacturer recommends.
Can I fry a frozen turkey?
No. Thaw the turkey completely in the refrigerator before frying. Frozen or partly frozen birds can cause dangerous oil splatter.
Do I need to inject or brine the turkey?
Neither is required. Injection adds flavor, but keep liquids to a minimum because excess moisture increases spattering.
How do I clean the fryer after use?
Let the oil cool completely, then strain and store it for reuse or dispose of it according to local guidelines. Wash the basket and pot with warm soapy water, and dry all parts thoroughly before storing.
Where can I read about other turkey fryer options?
For a wider comparison, see 6 Best Indoor Electric Turkey Fryers for Safe Holiday Frying and Turkey Deep Fryer Kit: How to Choose, Set Up and Fry Safely.
Conclusion
The Masterbuilt Butterball turkey fryer XL can produce a juicy, golden turkey when you follow the manual, thaw the bird fully, and verify doneness with a thermometer. Plan your timeline, measure your oil and bird carefully, and keep safety rules front and center. Consult the manufacturer’s manual or a qualified professional if you have questions about installation or use in your home.

