Updated November 2026

Shoppers searching for a butterball turkey burger air fryer usually want one of two things: a quick way to cook frozen or fresh turkey burgers without heating up a full oven, or a dedicated appliance that handles lean ground turkey without drying it out. This list covers six products from the Butterball and Masterbuilt family, plus a related air-fryer-style cooker, so you can match the right model to your kitchen, your cooking habits and the size of meal you plan to make. Selection criteria were specification clarity, brand reputation for turkey cooking, typical owner feedback patterns, and how well each model suits everyday burger cooking versus full-bird holiday frying.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1Charbroil The Big Easy Oil-Less Turkey FryerTOP CHOICEBest overallCharbroil The Big Easy Oil-Less Turkey FryerView on Amazon
  2. 2Butterball Indoor Electric 20LB Turkey FryerTOP CHOICEBest for small kitchensButterball Indoor Electric 20LB Turkey FryerView on Amazon
  3. 3Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer 14LBTOP CHOICEBest budget pickMasterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer 14LBView on Amazon
  4. 4Butterball Stainless Steel 14LB Indoor Electric Turkey FryerBest for stainless steel fansButterball Stainless Steel 14LB Indoor Electric Turkey FryerView on Amazon
  5. 5Deep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base for Butterball Electric Turkey FryerBest replacement partDeep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base for Butterball Electric Turkey FryerView on Amazon
  6. 6Masterbuilt Butterball MB23012418 XL Electric FryerBest for large batchesMasterbuilt Butterball MB23012418 XL Electric FryerView on Amazon

Our Top Picks

The table below summarizes how each product fits common needs. Each product section follows with specifications, strengths, limitations and a bottom-line recommendation.

Product Best for Key feature
Charbroil The Big Easy Oil-Less Turkey Fryer Outdoor, oil-free cooking Propane-powered, no frying oil
Butterball Indoor Electric 20LB Turkey Fryer Small kitchens Compact indoor electric body
Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer 14LB Budget-conscious buyers 1650-watt heating element
Butterball Stainless Steel 14LB Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer Stainless steel preference Stainless steel cooking basket
Deep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base for Butterball Repairing an existing fryer Replacement power cord and base
Masterbuilt Butterball MB23012418 XL Electric Fryer Large batches and families XL capacity for bigger birds

Charbroil The Big Easy Oil-Less Turkey Fryer

Charbroil The Big Easy Oil-Less Turkey Fryer | Outdoor Air Fryer | Propane Cooker | Black

Charbroil The Big Easy Oil-Less Turkey Fryer | Outdoor Air Fryer | Propane Cooker | Black

View on Amazon

Best for: Outdoor, oil-free cooking

This model suits cooks who want the convection-style results of a turkey fryer without buying or disposing of large amounts of cooking oil. It is aimed at backyard use rather than kitchen countertops.

Key specs

  • Oil-less convection design
  • Propane-powered operation
  • Black finish

Pros

  • No frying oil required
  • Lower cleanup compared with traditional oil frying
  • Works well for patio or driveway cooking

Cons

  • Requires an outdoor setup and propane supply
  • Not suited for indoor or apartment use

Bottom line: Best for households with outdoor space that want a safer, oil-free alternative to traditional frying.

View on Amazon

Butterball Indoor Electric 20LB Turkey Fryer

Butterball Indoor Electric 20LB Turkey Fryer. 23011815

Butterball Indoor Electric 20LB Turkey Fryer. 23011815

View on Amazon

Best for: Small kitchens

Designed for indoor use, this electric fryer fits households that want to cook a turkey or large batch of food on the counter. It suits smaller kitchens where a full outdoor setup is not practical.

Key specs

  • Indoor electric operation
  • 20-pound rated capacity

Pros

  • Indoor use without outdoor propane
  • Compact footprint for an electric fryer
  • Straightforward electric controls

Cons

  • Capacity may be tight for very large birds
  • Requires a dedicated outlet with enough amperage

Bottom line: A practical choice for indoor cooks who want electric convenience in a space-limited kitchen.

View on Amazon

Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer 14LB

Masterbuilt - Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer - Black - 1650 WATTS - COMMERICAL GRADED - FOR HOME OR BUSINESS USE - FITS 14LB TURKEY

Masterbuilt – Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer – Black – 1650 WATTS – COMMERICAL GRADED – FOR HOME OR BUSINESS USE – FITS 14LB TURKEY

View on Amazon

Best for: Budget-conscious buyers

This model targets shoppers who want a dependable indoor electric fryer for a standard-size turkey or a steady supply of burgers and sides, without moving into the premium tier.

Key specs

  • 1650-watt heating element
  • Rated for birds up to 14 pounds
  • Commercial-graded construction for home or business use

Pros

  • Strong wattage for consistent heat
  • Fits common holiday turkey sizes
  • Usable beyond turkey, such as burgers and fries

Cons

  • Capacity is limited for larger birds
  • Requires careful attention to temperature and cleanup

Bottom line: A sensible pick for buyers who want a standard-size electric fryer without paying for extra capacity they will not use.

View on Amazon

Butterball Stainless Steel 14LB Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer

BUTTERBALL STAINLESS STEEL14LB INDOOR ELECTRIC TURKEY FRYER - also Fry & steam and boil all your favorite foods, butterball professional series by MASTERBUILT - USE YEAR ROUND - 1650 WATTS

BUTTERBALL STAINLESS STEEL14LB INDOOR ELECTRIC TURKEY FRYER – also Fry & steam and boil all your favorite foods, butterball professional series by MASTERBUILT – USE YEAR ROUND – 1650 WATTS

View on Amazon

Best for: Stainless steel preference

Shoppers who prefer stainless steel cooking surfaces for easier cleaning and a more durable finish will find this model appealing. It also works for steaming and boiling, not just frying.

Key specs

  • Stainless steel construction
  • 1650-watt heating element
  • 14-pound rated capacity
  • Designed for year-round use

Pros

  • Stainless steel is generally easy to wipe clean
  • Versatile for frying, steaming and boiling
  • Suitable for year-round use beyond holidays

Cons

  • Capacity is limited to mid-sized birds
  • Stainless surfaces can show water spots without drying

Bottom line: A good fit for cooks who want one indoor electric appliance for turkey, burgers and everyday steaming.

View on Amazon

Deep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base for Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer

Deep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base for Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer Parts and Masterbuilt Turkey Fryer Cord Fits 1650W Models Magnetic Cable for Misplaced Cord Replacement MB20012420 MB20010326

Deep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base for Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer Parts and Masterbuilt Turkey Fryer Cord Fits 1650W Models Magnetic Cable for Misplaced Cord Replacement MB20012420 MB20010326

View on Amazon

Best for: Replacement part

This is not a cooking appliance. It is a replacement cord and base for owners of compatible Butterball and Masterbuilt 1650-watt electric fryers who need to restore a damaged or misplaced power cord.

Key specs

  • Replacement cord with base
  • Designed for 1650-watt electric fryer models
  • Listed compatible model numbers in the product name

Pros

  • Avoids replacing a whole fryer over a cord issue
  • Compatibility is stated in the listing
  • Magnetic cable design for easier storage

Cons

  • Only useful for compatible models
  • Installation should follow the manufacturer’s instructions and safety guidance

Bottom line: Worth considering only if you already own a compatible electric fryer and need a cord replacement.

View on Amazon

Masterbuilt Butterball MB23012418 XL Electric Fryer

Masterbuilt Butterball MB23012418 XL Electric Fryer

Masterbuilt Butterball MB23012418 XL Electric Fryer

View on Amazon

Best for: Large batches and families

For households that cook for crowds or want to fry a larger bird, the XL format offers more interior room than the 14-pound models. It suits families and holiday hosts.

Key specs

  • XL capacity for larger turkeys
  • Electric operation

Pros

  • Room for bigger birds or multiple burgers at once
  • Electric operation avoids outdoor propane
  • Well suited to holiday cooking schedules

Cons

  • Larger footprint than compact models
  • Needs adequate counter or storage space

Bottom line: The right choice for cooks who regularly serve large groups and want an electric XL option.

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Capacity and bird size

Check the rated capacity before buying. A 14-pound rating suits a standard holiday turkey or a generous batch of burgers, while XL models are better for larger birds or groups. Owners often report that capacity limits are the most common reason for returns, so plan around your largest typical cook.

Good picks for this: Masterbuilt Butterball MB23012418 XL Electric Fryer, Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer 14LB

Indoor versus outdoor use

Electric indoor models avoid propane and open-flame setup, while outdoor propane cookers need open space and a safe distance from structures. Choose based on where you will actually cook.

Good picks for this: Butterball Indoor Electric 20LB Turkey Fryer, Charbroil The Big Easy Oil-Less Turkey Fryer

Wattage and heating performance

Most listed electric models in this group are rated at 1650 watts. Higher wattage generally means faster heat recovery, but manufacturers also specify preheat times that matter more than raw numbers for even cooking.

Good picks for this: Butterball Stainless Steel 14LB Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer 14LB

Oil use and cleanup

Traditional frying requires large volumes of oil, which adds cost, storage and disposal concerns. Oil-less and electric models reduce or remove this step. If you prefer no oil at all, prioritize oil-less designs.

Good picks for this: Charbroil The Big Easy Oil-Less Turkey Fryer, Butterball Stainless Steel 14LB Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer

Materials and durability

Stainless steel surfaces are generally easier to clean and resist staining better than painted finishes. Check whether the cooking basket and housing are removable for washing.

Good picks for this: Butterball Stainless Steel 14LB Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, Masterbuilt Butterball MB23012418 XL Electric Fryer

Replacement parts and compatibility

If a cord or base fails, a compatible replacement can extend the life of an existing fryer. Always confirm the model number matches your appliance before buying.

Good picks for this: Deep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base for Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer

Care and storage

Plan for cool-down time, drying all parts before storage, and keeping the cord away from hot surfaces. Follow the manufacturer’s cleaning instructions for the basket and heating element.

Good picks for this: Butterball Stainless Steel 14LB Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, Butterball Indoor Electric 20LB Turkey Fryer

FAQ

Can I cook turkey burgers in a Butterball turkey fryer?

Many Butterball electric fryers are designed for frying and steaming a range of foods, but whether they suit burgers depends on the model and included accessories. Check the manufacturer’s guidance on food types and always cook ground turkey to a safe internal temperature of 165°F, as the USDA recommends.

What internal temperature should turkey burgers reach?

The USDA advises cooking ground turkey to 165°F. Use a food thermometer in the thickest part of the patty.

Is an indoor electric turkey fryer safer than an outdoor propane model?

Electric indoor models avoid open flames and propane, which removes some hazards, but they still generate heat and require safe placement and cord management. Read the manual before use.

Do I need oil for an oil-less turkey fryer?

No. Oil-less designs are built to cook without frying oil. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions for preheating and loading.

What size turkey fits a 14-pound electric fryer?

The listing rates these models for birds up to about 14 pounds. Confirm the rated capacity in the product listing before buying a bird.

Can I replace a damaged cord on my Butterball fryer?

Compatible replacement cords exist for certain 1650-watt models. Confirm the model number matches, and if you are unsure about wiring or repair, consult a qualified appliance technician.

Conclusion

For most households, the Butterball Indoor Electric 20LB Turkey Fryer and Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer 14LB cover everyday indoor cooking well. Cooks who need more capacity should consider the XL model, while outdoor, oil-free cooking points toward the Charbroil Big Easy style cooker. The stainless steel model suits those who value easy cleaning, and the cord replacement is only relevant if you already own a compatible fryer.

Sources

Ethan Brooks

About Ethan Brooks

Ethan Brooks is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our holiday cooking & baking guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.