This post contains Amazon affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Roasting a turkey or holiday roast depends a lot on the pan under it. Size, material, oven temperature limits, and whether a rack or lid is included can change how the bird browns and how easy cleanup feels. We compared the listed specifications for five popular roasting pans to find the best roasting pan for different holiday cooking styles.
These picks were chosen by comparing the features and specs in each product listing. We have not tested any of these pans, so the recommendations below are based solely on the information the manufacturers published. Check each current listing for up-to-date prices, availability, and any extra details before ordering.
If you want a deeper walkthrough of the specs that matter, our roasting pan buying guide covers size, material, rack, and oven compatibility in more detail.
Our Picks at a Glance
The five pans below represent different approaches: large stainless steel roasters, a lighter nonstick pan, two enameled steel options, and a high-heat stainless model. We compared the listed dimensions, materials, oven temperatures, included racks or lids, and care instructions. We did not test the pans, and prices and ratings change frequently, so confirm the details on each product page before buying.
The Five Picks in More Detail
Cuisinart Chef’s Classic 16-inch roasting pan: Best for large stove-to-oven roasts
The Cuisinart Chef’s Classic is a 16-inch stainless steel roaster with a removable stainless rack. The listed outer dimensions are 20.7 inches long, 12 inches wide, and 4.9 inches high, giving it room for a large family roast. The mirror-finish uncoated stainless surface is described as non-reactive, and the aluminum-encapsulated base is meant to spread heat evenly across the pan. It is oven safe up to 500°F, listed as broiler-ready, and induction-compatible, so it can move from stovetop to oven without a problem.
The included rack lifts the meat so drippings collect in the pan for gravy, and the riveted stainless handles are secure but can get hot, so oven mitts are recommended. It is dishwasher safe according to the listing, though hand washing is recommended to keep the polish bright. A lifetime warranty is listed.
Specs that matter: Stainless steel with aluminum-encapsulated base; 20.7 x 12 x 4.9 inches; oven safe up to 500°F; broiler-ready; induction-compatible; stainless rack included; dishwasher safe but hand washing recommended; lifetime warranty listed.
Best for: Large turkeys and roasts that need stovetop versatility, a stainless surface, and a reliable nonstick-free cooking finish.
Glad 15-inch nonstick roasting pan: Best for easy-release cleanup
The Glad roasting pan is a 15-inch rectangular pan made from carbon steel with a nonstick coating. Its base measures 15 x 10.3 x 2.8 inches excluding handles, so it fits moderate-size turkeys, chickens, beef roasts, and vegetable bakes. The listing describes a V-shaped iron rack that increases airflow around the food for more consistent roasting.
The nonstick surface is designed for easier release and quick cleaning, and the pan is listed as dishwasher safe. The care instructions also recommend washing it in warm soapy water before first use, towel drying after each wash, avoiding soaking, and skipping harsh abrasive tools. It is oven safe up to 464°F but is not for stovetop use, open flames, or broiler use.
Specs that matter: Carbon steel with nonstick coating; 15 x 10.3 x 2.8 inches excluding handles; oven safe up to 464°F; V-shaped iron rack described; not stovetop safe; not broiler safe; listed dishwasher safe with special care steps.
Best for: Turkey, chicken, and vegetable roasts where easy cleanup and a nonstick release surface are the top priorities.
Granite Ware 13-inch oval roaster: Best for small covered roasts and sourdough baking
The Granite Ware roaster is a 13-inch oval pan made from porcelain enamel on steel. It is listed as fitting up to 7 pounds of poultry or roast, which makes it a better match for smaller holiday meals. A tight-fitting, self-basting lid is included, and the enamel surface is described as smooth, easy to clean, and free of PFOA and PTFE.
One unusual feature is its very high oven temperature rating: the listing says it can withstand up to 932°F, which makes it suitable for high-heat sourdough bread baking as well as roasting. The covered design traps steam for a crisp crust and moist interior, and the pan is dishwasher safe. The listing also describes the pan as an oval bread cloche for artisan-style loaves.
Specs that matter: Enameled steel; 13-inch oval; listed capacity up to 7 lb; oven safe up to 932°F; self-basting lid included; PFOA- and PTFE-free; dishwasher safe.
Best for: Smaller turkeys, covered roasts, and bakers who want one pan for roasting and sourdough bread.
Granitebowl 18-inch turkey roaster with lid: Best for very large covered turkeys
The Granitebowl roaster is an 18-inch pan with a lid, made from a carbon steel core with an enamel finish. The outer dimensions are 18 inches long and 12.8 inches wide, while the inside is listed as 15 by 11 inches. With the lid on, the listing says the pan can hold up to 16 pounds of poultry, so it is a strong option for a big Thanksgiving turkey.
The enamel surface is described as evenly absorbing and distributing heat while locking in moisture. The pan is free of PFOA and PTFE and is dishwasher safe, though the listing warns against using overly hard tools that could damage the enamel coating. Heat source compatibility has limits: the roaster is not for glass ovens, induction cookers, or microwave ovens.
Specs that matter: Carbon steel core with enamel finish; 18 x 12.8 inches outside, 15 x 11 inches inside; listed capacity up to 16 lb with lid; high-temperature resistance listed but no exact oven temperature; not for induction, glass ovens, or microwave; dishwasher safe.
Best for: Very large turkeys, Christmas hams, and covered holiday roasts where capacity matters most.
All-Clad 13 by 16-inch stainless roaster: Best for high-heat roasting and broiling
The All-Clad roaster is a large 13 by 16 inch pan made of polished stainless steel. The listing describes heavy-gauge construction and a nonstick V-shaped rack that raises food for airflow and even cooking. It is oven and broiler safe up to 600°F, while the nonstick rack is rated up to 375°F, so the rack has a lower heat ceiling than the pan itself.
This roaster is compatible with any stovetop except induction and is dishwasher safe. It comes with a limited lifetime warranty from All-Clad. The listing also includes a 25-pound capacity in the item description, and the pan is designed in Canonsburg, PA while being made in China.
Specs that matter: Polished stainless steel; 13 x 16 inches; listed capacity 25 lb; oven and broiler safe up to 600°F; nonstick rack rated up to 375°F; not induction-compatible; dishwasher safe; limited lifetime warranty.
Best for: Large roasts, high-heat oven cooking, and broiler use where a heavy stainless pan with a high heat rating fits the job.
How to Choose
Before picking a roasting pan, think about the turkey size, oven space, material preferences, and how much cleanup effort you want. The five models above show that the “best” choice changes depending on those priorities. Start with the basics below, and check current listings for exact numbers and any updated details.
Size and Capacity
Pan dimensions tell you whether a bird will fit without crowding the oven. The Cuisinart lists outer dimensions of 20.7 x 12 x 4.9 inches, the Glad pan is 15 x 10.3 x 2.8 inches excluding handles, and the Granitebowl is 18 x 12.8 inches outside with a 15 x 11 inch interior. The All-Clad is 13 x 16 inches, and the Granite Ware is a 13-inch oval. Listed capacities also differ: Granitebowl lists up to 16 pounds with the lid, Granite Ware lists up to 7 pounds, and All-Clad’s item description lists 25 pounds. If you make turkey stock after the meal, our turkey stock guide is a useful next step.
Material and Finish
The main materials among these picks are stainless steel, carbon steel with a nonstick coating, and enameled steel. Stainless steel pans, like the Cuisinart and All-Clad, are listed as non-reactive and often work on several heat sources. Nonstick carbon steel, like the Glad, focuses on easy release and faster cleanup. Enameled steel, like the Granite Ware and Granitebowl, offers a smooth surface without PFOA or PTFE in the listed finishes. Material trade-offs are similar to what you see with skillets, so our skillet material guide can help you compare the broader cookware ideas.
Oven Temperature and Heat Source Limits
Oven tolerance matters if you use high heat or broil. Cuisinart lists 500°F, All-Clad lists 600°F, Glad lists 464°F, and Granite Ware lists a very high 932°F. Granitebowl says it has high-temperature resistance but does not list a precise oven temperature limit, so check the listing for that number. Stovetop compatibility varies too: Cuisinart is induction-compatible, All-Clad works on any stovetop except induction, Glad says not for stovetop use, Granitebowl is not for induction, glass ovens, or microwave, and Granite Ware does not specify stovetop use.
Rack and Lid
A rack lifts the roast for airflow and keeps it out of the drippings. The Cuisinart, Glad, and All-Clad listings describe racks. A lid, on the other hand, traps steam and can promote basting. The Granite Ware includes a self-basting lid, and the Granitebowl includes a lid. If you often roast covered, a lid makes a real difference; if you prefer open roasting and broiling, prioritize rack airflow and a broiler-safe pan.
Cleaning and Care
Most of these pans are listed as dishwasher safe, but the care instructions are not identical. Cuisinart says hand washing is recommended to keep the polish bright. Glad gives detailed warnings about not soaking, not washing while hot, and avoiding abrasive tools. Granitebowl warns against hard cleaning tools that could scratch the enamel. Granite Ware lists dishwasher safe, and All-Clad lists dishwasher safe. Read the full care section in each listing before deciding how much maintenance you are willing to do.
| Product | Material | Dimensions | Oven Temperature | Capacity and Rack/Lid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cuisinart Chef’s Classic 16-inch | Stainless steel with aluminum-encapsulated base | 20.7 x 12 x 4.9 inches | Up to 500°F | Capacity not listed; stainless rack included |
| Glad 15-inch nonstick | Carbon steel with nonstick coating | 15 x 10.3 x 2.8 inches excluding handles | Up to 464°F | Capacity not listed; V-shaped iron rack described |
| Granite Ware 13-inch oval | Enameled steel | 13-inch oval | Up to 932°F | Up to 7 lb; self-basting lid included |
| Granitebowl 18-inch | Carbon steel core with enamel finish | 18 x 12.8 inches outside; 15 x 11 inches inside | Not listed | Up to 16 lb with lid; lid included |
| All-Clad 13 by 16-inch | Polished stainless steel | 13 x 16 inches | Up to 600°F; rack up to 375°F | Listed capacity 25 lb; nonstick rack included |
FAQ
Which roasting pan can handle the largest turkey?
Among the listed capacities, the All-Clad roaster lists a 25-pound capacity, the Granitebowl lists up to 16 pounds with the lid, and the Granite Ware lists up to 7 pounds. The Cuisinart and Glad listings do not state a capacity in pounds, so compare their dimensions with the turkey size and check the product listing for more detail.
What is the difference between a nonstick and an enameled roasting pan?
Nonstick pans like the Glad use a coated carbon steel surface for easy release. Enameled pans like the Granite Ware and Granitebowl use a glass-like enamel finish over steel. Both are listed as easier to clean than uncoated stainless, but care instructions differ. The Granite Ware and Granitebowl are also listed as PFOA- and PTFE-free, while the Glad listing focuses on its nonstick coating and dishwasher-safe care routine.
Are these pans safe to use under the broiler?
Only some are listed as broiler-safe. The Cuisinart is described as broiler-ready and oven safe to 500°F. The All-Clad is oven and broiler safe up to 600°F, though its nonstick rack is only rated to 375°F. The Glad listing says it is not broiler safe. The Granite Ware and Granitebowl listings do not mention broiler use, so check the product page before using either under a broiler.
Can I use these roasting pans on the stovetop?
Heat source compatibility varies. The Cuisinart is listed as usable both in the oven and on the stovetop, including induction. The All-Clad works on any stovetop except induction. The Glad is not for stovetop use or open flames. The Granitebowl is compatible with multiple heat sources but is not for induction, glass ovens, or microwave ovens. The Granite Ware listing does not specify stovetop compatibility, so if you plan to start a roast on the stove, verify it before purchasing.
Choosing the right roasting pan comes down to the turkey size, oven and stovetop compatibility, and how much cleanup you want. Use the table above as a starting point, then check current listings for updated pricing and details. Once the meal is finished, save the carcass and use our turkey stock recipe to get the most from the bird.
