Updated November 2026
Roasting patty pan squash works best when you start with a variety that holds its shape, stays tender and matures fast enough for your growing season. This list compares five patty pan seed options sold on Amazon US, judged on fruit type, days to harvest, plant habit and how well each suits roasting, grilling and sautéing. Product details below come from manufacturer listings and common owner feedback, not hands-on trials.
Our top picks at a glance
- 1
TOP CHOICEBest overallBmore Spicy Lunar Eclipse Patty Pan Squash Seeds – F1 HybridView on Amazon - 2
TOP CHOICEBest for heirloom planting50 White Patty Pan Squash Heirloom Vegetable SeedsView on Amazon - 3
TOP CHOICEBest for mixed colorsTomorrowSeeds 3 Colors Mix Patty Pan SeedsView on Amazon - 4
Best for a bigger harvestBennings Green Tint Summer Squash SeedsView on Amazon - 5
Best for a small seed budgetKIRA SEEDS Green Patty Pan Bush SquashView on Amazon
Our Top Picks
| Product | Best for | Key feature |
|---|---|---|
| Bmore Spicy Lunar Eclipse Patty Pan Squash Seeds | Overall roasting | F1 hybrid, fast maturing |
| 50 White Patty Pan Squash Heirloom Vegetable Seeds | Heirloom planting | Compact bush, 54-day harvest |
| TomorrowSeeds 3 Colors Mix Patty Pan Seeds | Mixed-color dishes | Yellow, green and white fruit |
| Bennings Green Tint Summer Squash Seeds | Larger harvest | Productive warm-season plant |
| KIRA SEEDS Green Patty Pan | Small seed budget | Heirloom bush squash |
Bmore Spicy Lunar Eclipse Patty Pan Squash Seeds – F1 Hybrid
Bmore Spicy Lunar Eclipse Patty Pan Squash Seeds – F1 Hybrid – Pale Green Scallop Summer Squash – Non-GMO – Fast Maturing – 10 Seeds – Ideal for Grilling, Roasting & Sautéing
Best for: Overall roasting and grilling
A strong all-round choice for gardeners who want uniform, pale green scallops that roast evenly and hold their shape in the pan.
Pros
- F1 hybrid listing emphasizes uniform fruit
- Listing describes fast maturing fruit
Cons
- Hybrid seed means saved seed will not breed true
50 White Patty Pan Squash Heirloom Vegetable Seeds
50 White Patty Pan Squash Heirloom Vegetable Seeds, Cucurbita Pepo | USA Packed, Heirloom, Non-GMO Seeds for Planting, Vegetable, Summer Scallop, Creamy Flavor, Compact Bush, Fast 54 Day Harvest
Best for: Heirloom planting and seed saving
Suited to gardeners who want open-pollinated seed and a compact plant that fits small beds or raised planters.
Pros
- Listed as heirloom, so seed can be saved
- Compact bush habit with a 54-day harvest window
Cons
- White fruit can look pale after roasting without seasoning
TomorrowSeeds 3 Colors Mix Patty Pan Seeds
TomorrowSeeds – 3 Colors Mix Patty Pan (Bush Scallop Squash) Seeds – 60+ Count – For 2026 Planting Yellow, Green Tint, White Bush Scallop Summer Squash Patisson Scallopini Vegetable Grow Your Own Home
Best for: Mixed-color roasting trays
Good for cooks who want yellow, green and white scallops on one plate, and for anyone planting more than one color for variety.
Pros
- Three colors in one packet
- Large seed count for succession planting
Cons
- Mixed colors may ripen at slightly different rates
Bennings Green Tint Summer Squash Seeds
Bennings Green Tint Summer Squash Seeds (Cucurbita Pepo) – 30+ Non-GMO Heirloom Seeds by Isla’s Garden Seeds, Tender Patty Pan Type w/Pale Green Fruits, Mild Flavor, Productive Warm-Season Crop
Best for: A larger harvest from one planting
Aimed at gardeners who want steady production of pale green scallops for roasting across the summer.
Pros
- Listed as productive warm-season plant
- Mild flavor suits simple seasoning
Cons
- Needs warm soil and full sun to perform well
KIRA SEEDS Green Patty Pan Bush Squash
Best for: A small seed budget
A practical pick for first-time growers who want a simple bush squash for roasting without buying a large assortment.
Pros
- Listed as heirloom and GMO free
- Bush habit takes less garden space
Cons
- Smaller listing details than some competing packets
Buying Guide
Fruit color and flavor
Pale green and yellow scallops tend to have a mild, buttery flavor when roasted. White varieties are often described as creamier, though they can look plain on the plate without herbs or a sprinkle of cheese.
Hybrid or heirloom seed
Hybrid seed usually gives uniform fruit but will not produce true-to-type plants if you save seed. Heirloom seed can be saved year to year, which suits gardeners who want to keep a line going.
Days to harvest
Check the days-to-maturity figure on the packet and count back from your first expected frost date. Fast-maturing varieties give you more room for a second planting in short-season areas.
Plant habit
Bush types stay compact and suit small beds and containers. Vining types sprawl and need more room. Most patty pans are bush-type, which makes them easier to fit into a home garden.
Good picks for this: Bmore Spicy Lunar Eclipse Patty Pan Squash Seeds and KIRA SEEDS Green Patty Pan
FAQ
Do I need to peel patty pan squash before roasting?
No. The skin is thin and tender, so most cooks leave it on. Just wash the fruit and trim the stem end before cutting.
Related reading
- Why Is My Nonstick Roasting Pan with Rack Sticking? 5 Causes and Fixes
- What to Cook in a Roasting Pan: 8 Holiday Dishes That Work Well
- What Is a Shallow Roasting Pan? Uses, Size and How to Choose One
- What Is a Roasting Pan Used For? Uses, Tips and Holiday Examples
- What Does Roasting Pan Look Like? A Quick Visual Guide for Holiday Cooks
- Turkey in a Roasting Pan: A Step-by-Step Guide for Holiday Cooks

