Updated November 2026

Shopping for christmas cookies from pillsbury cookie dough is mostly a question of flavor and how much effort you want to spend on the day. This list compares five refrigerated doughs sold on Amazon by what each one is best at, based on product listings, brand information and common owner feedback. The criteria: ease of baking, flavor profile, how well the dough suits decorating or gifting, and whether the package fits a typical holiday baking schedule.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1Pillsbury Sugar Cookie Dough, Makes 24 Cookies, 16 ozTOP CHOICEBest overallPillsbury Sugar Cookie Dough, Makes 24 Cookies, 16 ozView on Amazon
  2. 2Pillsbury Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Makes 24 Cookies, 16 ozTOP CHOICEBest for chocolate loversPillsbury Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Makes 24 Cookies, 16 ozView on Amazon
  3. 3Pillsbury REESE'S Peanut Butter Cookie Dough, Makes 24 Cookies, 16 ozTOP CHOICEBest for peanut butter fansPillsbury REESE'S Peanut Butter Cookie Dough, Makes 24 Cookies, 16 ozView on Amazon
  4. 4Ann Clark Gingerbread Cookie Mix, 16 ozBest for a gingerbread twistAnn Clark Gingerbread Cookie Mix, 16 ozView on Amazon
  5. 5Old World Christmas Pillsbury Doughboy Glass OrnamentBest for gift-giving decorOld World Christmas Pillsbury Doughboy Glass OrnamentView on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Product Best for Key feature
Pillsbury Sugar Cookie Dough Decorating and gifting Place and bake, 24 cookies
Pillsbury Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Chocolate lovers Made with real chocolate
Pillsbury REESE’S Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Peanut butter fans Real REESE’S peanut butter
Ann Clark Gingerbread Cookie Mix Classic holiday flavor Rich ginger flavor
Old World Christmas Pillsbury Doughboy Glass Ornament Tree decoration Handcrafted blown glass
Pillsbury Refrigerated Sugar Cookie Dough, Makes 24 Cookies, 16 oz | Place & Bake — No Mixing Or Mess, Safe To Eat Raw — Look For The Seal, Great For Dessert Bars, Parties & Gift Baskets

Pillsbury Refrigerated Sugar Cookie Dough, Makes 24 Cookies, 16 oz | Place & Bake — No Mixing Or Mess, Safe To Eat Raw — Look For The Seal, Great For Dessert Bars, Parties & Gift Baskets

View on Amazon

Best for: Decorating and gifting

This is the most flexible option for a Christmas cookie tray, especially if you plan to cut shapes and decorate with icing or sprinkles. It suits bakers who want a neutral, buttery base.

Pros

  • Place-and-bake format with no mixing required
  • Works well for bars, party platters and gift baskets

Cons

  • Plain flavor needs decorating to feel festive
View on Amazon
Pillsbury Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Makes 24 Cookies, 16 oz | Made With Real Chocolate, No High Fructose Corn Syrup Or Artificial Color Sources, Safe To Eat Raw, No Mixing Or Mess

Pillsbury Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Makes 24 Cookies, 16 oz | Made With Real Chocolate, No High Fructose Corn Syrup Or Artificial Color Sources, Safe To Eat Raw, No Mixing Or Mess

View on Amazon

Best for: Chocolate lovers

A good match for families who want a familiar, crowd-pleasing cookie without any shaping or chilling. It also works well as a quick dessert when guests drop by.

Pros

  • Made with real chocolate pieces
  • Dough is labeled safe to eat raw, which helps when kids want to snack on it

Cons

  • Less suited to detailed decorating
View on Amazon
Pillsbury REESE'S Peanut Butter Cookie Dough, Makes 24 Cookies, 16 oz | Real REESE'S Peanut Butter, Safe To Eat Raw, No Mixing Or Mess, Great For Parties & Gift Baskets

Pillsbury REESE'S Peanut Butter Cookie Dough, Makes 24 Cookies, 16 oz | Real REESE'S Peanut Butter, Safe To Eat Raw, No Mixing Or Mess, Great For Parties & Gift Baskets

View on Amazon

Best for: Peanut butter fans

Aimed at guests who favor peanut butter desserts, this dough brings a richer, nutty profile to a holiday tray. It is a practical choice for parties where a distinctive flavor stands out.

Pros

  • Uses real REESE’S peanut butter for a recognizable flavor
  • No mixing or mess, suited to busy schedules

Cons

  • Not ideal for guests with peanut allergies
View on Amazon
Ann Clark Gingerbread Cookie Mix, 16 oz | Classic Christmas Cookies, Rich Ginger Flavor, Premium Ingredients, Family Business for Over 35 Years

Ann Clark Gingerbread Cookie Mix, 16 oz | Classic Christmas Cookies, Rich Ginger Flavor, Premium Ingredients, Family Business for Over 35 Years

View on Amazon

Best for: A gingerbread twist

This is a mix rather than a ready-to-bake dough, so it fits bakers who enjoy a little more hands-on work. It is a good choice when you want classic spiced holiday cookies.

Pros

  • Delivers a rich, classic ginger flavor
  • Brand has a long history with holiday baking

Cons

  • Requires adding ingredients, so it is not a pure dough shortcut
View on Amazon

Old World Christmas Pillsbury Doughboy Glass Ornament

Old World Christmas Pillsbury Doughboy Glass Ornament for Tree | Handcrafted Blown Glass Vintage Christmas Tree Ornament, Holiday Decoration with Keepsake Box, Food-Baking Collection

Old World Christmas Pillsbury Doughboy Glass Ornament for Tree | Handcrafted Blown Glass Vintage Christmas Tree Ornament, Holiday Decoration with Keepsake Box, Food-Baking Collection

View on Amazon

Best for: Gift-giving decor

This is not edible, but it pairs well with a cookie-baking gift for a baker on your list. Owners often report it works as a keepsake tree ornament.

Pros

  • Handcrafted blown glass with a keepsake box
  • Fits a baking-themed holiday décor collection

Cons

  • Fragile, so handle with care when hanging
View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Flavor profile

Decide whether your guests prefer classic sugar, chocolate, peanut butter or spiced flavors. A mixed tray usually works best with one neutral dough and one bolder flavor.

Shaping and decorating

Sugar dough holds cut shapes better than drop-style doughs. If you plan to decorate with royal icing, choose a neutral base that will not compete with the frosting.

Baking time and effort

Place-and-bake doughs save time, but check your oven and pan size. Plan around the baking times printed on the package, and bake a test cookie before filling a full sheet.

Food safety and allergens

Read labels carefully for nut content and allergens before serving. If anyone in your household has a food allergy, consult a healthcare professional or allergist before serving.

Good picks for this: Pillsbury Sugar Cookie Dough and Pillsbury Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

Emily Parker

About Emily Parker

Emily Parker is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our holiday cooking & baking guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.