Updated November 2026

If your butterball electric turkey fryer parts have worn out, cracked or gone missing, the fastest way back to frying is usually a targeted replacement rather than a new fryer. Most people searching for butterball electric turkey fryer parts need one of three things: a structural part such as a lid hinge, an electrical part such as a power cord, or a cord assembly that includes its base connection. This guide narrows the field to three replacement parts sold on Amazon US that are built to fit Butterball and Masterbuilt-style indoor electric fryers. Our selection criteria were fit with the named models, electrical rating and gauge, build material, how cleanly the part mounts, and the consistency of owner feedback about fit and durability.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1KSGOOD Plastic hinge for Masterbuilt electric turkey deep fryer MB2001TOP CHOICEBest overallKSGOOD Plastic hinge for Masterbuilt electric turkey deep fryer MB2001View on Amazon
  2. 2VASTHOME Deep Fryer Cord Replacement for Hamilton Beach, Masterbuilt,Best for replacing a damaged power cordVASTHOME Deep Fryer Cord Replacement for Hamilton Beach, Masterbuilt,View on Amazon
  3. 3Deep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base for Butterball Electric Turkey FBest for a complete cord and base assemblyDeep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base for Butterball Electric Turkey FView on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Product Best for Key feature
KSGOOD Plastic Hinge for Masterbuilt Electric Turkey Deep Fryer Replacing a broken lid hinge Plastic hinge listed for specific Masterbuilt and Butterball XL model numbers
VASTHOME Deep Fryer Cord Replacement Replacing a frayed or damaged power cord 16 AWG flat power cord
Deep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base for Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer Parts Replacing a cord along with its base connection Cord with base, magnetic cable for misplaced cord replacement

KSGOOD Plastic Hinge for Masterbuilt Electric Turkey Deep Fryer MB20012420 MB20010326 Butterball XL 8L/10L Electric Fryer Parts

KSGOOD Plastic hinge for Masterbuilt electric turkey deep fryer MB20012420,MB20010326,butterball XL 8L/10L electric fryer parts

KSGOOD Plastic hinge for Masterbuilt electric turkey deep fryer MB20012420,MB20010326,butterball XL 8L/10L electric fryer parts

View on Amazon

Best for: Replacing a broken or cracked lid hinge on a compatible indoor electric fryer.

This is the right choice for owners whose fryer lid no longer sits securely or whose hinge has snapped. Because hinges take the most stress when the lid is opened and closed with hot oil nearby, a like-for-like replacement is often the most practical repair. For another angle, check out How to Wash Air Fryer Parts Safely: A Step-by-Step Guide for Beginners.

Key specs:

  • Plastic hinge part
  • Listed for Masterbuilt model numbers MB20012420 and MB20010326
  • Listed for Butterball XL 8L/10L electric fryer parts

Pros:

  • Targets a specific, common failure point
  • Model numbers are named in the listing, which helps confirm fit
  • Straightforward replacement without rewiring

Cons:

  • Fit depends on your exact model, so check the number on your unit first
  • Owners sometimes report that hinge screws need to be replaced along with the part

Bottom line: Best for owners whose lid hinge has broken and whose model number matches the listing.

View on Amazon

VASTHOME Deep Fryer Cord Replacement for Hamilton Beach, Masterbuilt, Butterball, Farberware, Secura, and Pukomc Electric Deep Fryers 16 AWG Flat Power Cord Replacement Part

VASTHOME Deep Fryer Cord Replacement for Hamilton Beach, Masterbuilt, Butterball, Farberware, Secura, and Pukomc Electric Deep Fryers - 16 AWG Flat Power Cord Replacement Part

VASTHOME Deep Fryer Cord Replacement for Hamilton Beach, Masterbuilt, Butterball, Farberware, Secura, and Pukomc Electric Deep Fryers – 16 AWG Flat Power Cord Replacement Part

View on Amazon

Best for: Replacing a frayed, cracked or intermittently faulty power cord on an electric deep fryer.

This suits owners who have a working fryer body but a damaged cord, especially when the appliance is otherwise sound. The listing covers several brands, so it is a useful option if your fryer’s branding is unclear.

Key specs:

  • 16 AWG flat power cord
  • Listed as a replacement for Hamilton Beach, Masterbuilt, Butterball, Farberware, Secura and Pukomc electric deep fryers

Pros:

  • Broad compatibility across several fryer brands
  • Gauge is stated in the listing so you can compare it with the original cord
  • Replacing only the cord avoids the cost and hassle of a new appliance

Cons:

  • Broad compatibility means you must verify the plug style and connector against your fryer
  • Wiring work near heating elements calls for care; a qualified technician should handle it if you are unsure

Bottom line: A sensible pick for anyone replacing a worn power cord who wants a generic-fit, widely listed part.

View on Amazon

Deep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base for Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer Parts and Masterbuilt Turkey Fryer Cord Fits 1650W Models

Deep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base for Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer Parts and Masterbuilt Turkey Fryer Cord Fits 1650W Models Magnetic Cable for Misplaced Cord Replacement MB20012420 MB20010326

Deep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base for Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer Parts and Masterbuilt Turkey Fryer Cord Fits 1650W Models Magnetic Cable for Misplaced Cord Replacement MB20012420 MB20010326

View on Amazon

Best for: Replacing a cord together with the base connection on 1650W Butterball and Masterbuilt-style fryers.

This is aimed at owners whose cord has come loose from the base or whose base connector has worn. Buying the cord and base as one assembly can reduce the number of connection points you have to troubleshoot.

Key specs:

  • Cord with base assembly
  • Listed for 1650W models
  • Listed model references include MB20012420 and MB20010326
  • Magnetic cable design for misplaced cord replacement

Pros:

  • Names Butterball and Masterbuilt model numbers directly
  • Includes the base, so the connection point is replaced too
  • Stated wattage helps confirm the fryer you have

Cons:

  • Only suits 1650W models; check your nameplate before ordering
  • Installation involves electrical connections and may be best left to a qualified technician

Bottom line: Best for owners of 1650W Butterball or Masterbuilt fryers who need a full cord and base replacement.

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Confirm your exact model number

Butterball and Masterbuilt indoor fryers share design features, but parts are often model-specific. Look for the model number on the label or nameplate, usually on the underside or back of the unit. Match it against the “compatible with” or model list in each listing before buying.

Good picks for this: KSGOOD Plastic Hinge, Deep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base

Check the wattage and electrical rating

Many indoor electric fryers are rated around 1650 watts, but ratings vary by model. Using a cord or base not rated for your appliance can cause overheating. Confirm the rating on your nameplate and match it to the part’s stated wattage.

Good picks for this: Deep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base, VASTHOME Deep Fryer Cord Replacement

Compare cord gauge and construction

Cord gauge (AWG) indicates conductor thickness; lower numbers mean thicker wire able to carry more current. A 16 AWG cord is a common specification for this class of appliance. Flat cords are common on fryers, so check that the shape matches the original.

Good picks for this: VASTHOME Deep Fryer Cord Replacement

Decide between a single part and an assembly

If only the hinge or only the cord is damaged, a single part keeps costs and disassembly low. If the connection at the base is also worn, an assembly that includes the base can be the more reliable fix.

Good picks for this: KSGOOD Plastic Hinge, Deep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base

Consider the material and durability

Hinges and housings are often plastic, and plastic can become brittle after repeated heating and cooling. Owners generally report better longevity when parts are fitted carefully and not forced, so check the hardware and alignment at installation.

Good picks for this: KSGOOD Plastic Hinge

Think about your use case

Frequent holiday use puts more strain on cords and hinges than occasional use. If you fry several birds each season, a replacement with a clearly stated gauge and model match is worth prioritizing over the lowest-looking option.

Good picks for this: VASTHOME Deep Fryer Cord Replacement, Deep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base

Plan for safe installation and care

Unplug the fryer and let it cool fully before replacing any part. Inspect the surrounding wiring for heat damage before reconnecting. If you are not comfortable with electrical work, a qualified appliance technician or the manufacturer’s service channel is the safer route. Keep the fryer away from water and never operate it with a damaged cord.

Good picks for this: Deep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base, KSGOOD Plastic Hinge

FAQ

Can I use a generic cord on a Butterball electric turkey fryer?

A generic cord can work if its plug style, wire gauge and wattage rating match your fryer. Compare the connector, the gauge and the rating against the original cord and nameplate before installing.

How do I find the model number on my fryer?

Check the nameplate or label on the underside or back of the unit. The model number is usually printed there. Use it to confirm compatibility with any replacement part.

Do I need to replace the hinge screws when I replace the hinge?

Owners sometimes report that original screws strip or loosen during removal. Inspect them before reassembly and replace them if they are worn or damaged.

Is it safe to replace a power cord myself?

Replacing a cord involves electrical connections close to heating elements. If you are not experienced with appliance wiring, consult a qualified appliance technician or the manufacturer’s service channel.

Why does my fryer cord get warm?

Warmth at the cord or plug can indicate a loose connection, an undersized cord or a fault. Unplug the appliance and have it inspected by a professional before further use.

Should I buy a whole new fryer instead of parts?

If the fryer body is cracked, the heating element has failed or the unit is old, a new appliance may be more practical. For a single worn hinge or cord, a targeted part is usually the more economical repair.

Conclusion

For a broken lid, the KSGOOD Plastic Hinge is the most direct fix when your model number matches. For a frayed or damaged power cord on a mixed-brand fryer, the VASTHOME Deep Fryer Cord Replacement offers broad compatibility with a stated 16 AWG gauge. If the cord and base connection are both worn on a 1650W Butterball or Masterbuilt unit, the Deep Fryer Cord Replacement with Base is the assembly to consider. In every case, confirm the model number and rating before ordering, and have electrical work checked by a qualified professional if you are unsure.

Sources

Ethan Brooks

About Ethan Brooks

Ethan Brooks is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our holiday cooking & baking guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.