Updated November 2026

Choosing a butterball electric turkey fryer professional series by masterbuilt comes down to three things: how big a bird you need to cook, whether you want indoor or outdoor-style convenience, and how much countertop or storage space you have. The picks below are based on product listings, brand positioning and common owner feedback patterns, with the focus on capacity, wattage, build and everyday practicality.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1Butterball Stainless Steel 14LB Indoor Electric Turkey FryerTOP CHOICEBest overallButterball Stainless Steel 14LB Indoor Electric Turkey FryerView on Amazon
  2. 2Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey FryerBest for a 14-pound turkey in a black finishMasterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey FryerView on Amazon
  3. 3Masterbuilt Butterball MB23012418 XL Electric FryerBest for larger birdsMasterbuilt Butterball MB23012418 XL Electric FryerView on Amazon
  4. 4Masterbuilt MB23010618 Fryer, XL Stainless SteelBest for a stainless steel XL setupMasterbuilt MB23010618 Fryer, XL Stainless SteelView on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Quick Comparison

Product Best for Key feature
Butterball Stainless Steel 14LB Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer Year-round all-purpose frying 1650 watts, steam and boil
Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer (Black) Fitting a 14-pound turkey Commercial-graded build
Masterbuilt Butterball MB23012418 XL Electric Fryer Larger holiday birds XL frying capacity
Masterbuilt MB23010618 Fryer, XL Stainless Steel Stainless steel XL setup Stainless steel XL body

Butterball Stainless Steel 14LB Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer

BUTTERBALL STAINLESS STEEL14LB INDOOR ELECTRIC TURKEY FRYER - also Fry & steam and boil all your favorite foods, butterball professional series by MASTERBUILT - USE YEAR ROUND - 1650 WATTS

BUTTERBALL STAINLESS STEEL14LB INDOOR ELECTRIC TURKEY FRYER – also Fry & steam and boil all your favorite foods, butterball professional series by MASTERBUILT – USE YEAR ROUND – 1650 WATTS

View on Amazon

Best for: Year-round all-purpose frying

This model suits cooks who want one appliance for turkey and other foods. Manufacturers specify 1650 watts and a steam and boil function alongside frying.

Pros

  • Stainless steel finish that fits a modern kitchen
  • Steam and boil functions add everyday use

Cons

  • Sized for a 14-pound turkey, so very large birds need another option
View on Amazon

Masterbuilt Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer

Masterbuilt - Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer - Black - 1650 WATTS - COMMERICAL GRADED - FOR HOME OR BUSINESS USE - FITS 14LB TURKEY

Masterbuilt – Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer – Black – 1650 WATTS – COMMERICAL GRADED – FOR HOME OR BUSINESS USE – FITS 14LB TURKEY

View on Amazon

Best for: Fitting a 14-pound turkey

Aimed at home cooks and small businesses, this black model is described by the brand as commercial-graded and rated at 1650 watts.

Pros

  • Manufacturer lists it as commercial-graded for heavier use
  • Clearly sized for a 14-pound turkey

Cons

  • Capacity is smaller than the XL models
View on Amazon

Masterbuilt Butterball MB23012418 XL Electric Fryer

Masterbuilt Butterball MB23012418 XL Electric Fryer

Masterbuilt Butterball MB23012418 XL Electric Fryer

View on Amazon

Best for: Larger holiday birds

This XL model is intended for households that regularly cook big birds or feed a crowd. Owners often report that the larger basket handles bigger turkeys than the standard 14-pound units.

Pros

  • XL capacity suits larger gatherings
  • Butterball branding matches the professional series line

Cons

  • Takes up more counter and storage space
View on Amazon

Masterbuilt MB23010618 Fryer, XL Stainless Steel

Masterbuilt MB23010618 Fryer, XL Stainless Steel

Masterbuilt MB23010618 Fryer, XL Stainless Steel

View on Amazon

Best for: Stainless steel XL setup

This option combines XL sizing with a stainless steel body, a good fit for cooks who want a larger fryer with a finish that matches other kitchen appliances.

Pros

  • Stainless steel construction is easy to wipe down
  • XL capacity for bigger birds

Cons

  • Larger footprint than the indoor 14-pound models
View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Turkey size and capacity

Check the maximum bird weight in the manufacturer’s specifications before you buy. The 14-pound indoor models suit smaller gatherings, while XL units handle larger birds.

Wattage and heating power

Manufacturers list the wattage for each model, and 1650 watts is a common rating in this line. Higher wattage generally means faster heat-up, but always follow the included manual. You may also like 7 Best Butterball Professional Series Electric Turkey Fryers for Holiday Frying.

Indoor use and ventilation

Indoor electric fryers avoid open flame and large volumes of hot oil outdoors, but the kitchen still needs good airflow. Plan counter space and a safe outlet before the holiday.

Build quality and finish

Stainless steel bodies are easier to clean and look consistent with other appliances. Commercial-graded labeling signals heavier-duty construction, though it does not replace reading the manual.

Good picks for this: Masterbuilt Butterball MB23012418 XL Electric Fryer and Masterbuilt MB23010618 Fryer, XL Stainless Steel

FAQ

What size turkey fits in a Butterball electric turkey fryer?

Many indoor models are sized for a 14-pound turkey, while XL versions accommodate larger birds. Check the listed capacity for the exact model you choose.

Is an electric turkey fryer safer than a propane model?

Electric fryers avoid open flame and do not require a gas burner, which many cooks find simpler indoors. Always follow the manufacturer’s safety instructions and keep the unit away from water and children.

Can I use these fryers for foods other than turkey?

Some models are marketed for steaming, boiling and frying other foods. Confirm the function list in the manual before using it for other recipes.

Ethan Brooks

About Ethan Brooks

Ethan Brooks is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our holiday cooking & baking guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.